Overall I think this is a fair list, some of these ratings do confuse me a bit though. You don't think Rinnesasuke is SS, with BT (you said BT forms were considered)? I don't have him 4 stars yet, and admittedly in my experience his non-bt form is pretty bad in terms of damage output, but a lot of people seem to be saying he's pretty strong with BT, around or a little under Edo Minato's tier. His BT are still pretty new so I think we're still in the figuring things out phase in terms of where he will truly end up in the tier list.
I'm also interested to know why you put Ay [4th] and Han [Edo] in S tier. Ay is good in theory, but I hardly ever see him. I don't think I've ever seen him with BTs. Maybe once. I think this list should reflect not only theoretical potential but also usage if it's going to be helpful to people in picking which ninjas to use. Han is kind of similar, I never see anyone use him. Their mysteries are kind of similar, since it's just multiple standard attacks. The big problem with that (in my opinion) is that it's not targeted damage. You may or may not hit the ninja you want, it's too random.
One other thing, if you revised/did this again in the future, might be to split it into pos 1 carry ninjas and support ninjas. Some of these guys can be both but there are some in the high tiers who are pretty much only support (Edo Itachi, 7 Swords Bee, Iruka, Shark Kisame, Summer Sakura, etc.). Idk. I'm not sure if this would really help but otherwise it is kind of comparing apples to oranges, imo.
Thanks for making this though, always nice to see tier lists and I'm interested to see more discussion.
Log in in order to Post. LOGIN | Register
Confirm Delete Selected Topics?
Confirm Delete The post you selected?