Don't have Kurenai, so tried following and it worked:

X X X
Guy Main Hinata
Karin X X

Skills: 3-3-1-1-2
Summon: Used Illusion Crow, but can be tested with any other

Tactic: first focus Jiraya, then Naruto
Round 1 - Hinata use Mystery.
Round 2 - Guy use Mystery on Jiraya, Karin use Mystery, Main use Mystery.
Round 3 - Hinata use Mystery, Guy use Mystery on Naruto