Actually, this matter is sensitive and will always create conflict as all people has their own definition of F2P .. And they will fight for what they believe is right and wrong ..

In my case, i am a full-time F2P .. never spent a cent on this game and never have a plan on the future (except if i saw major changes in this game that can convince me to spend) but an incident happened where my former Group Leader got his account locked because of some Recharge Problem which is not his fault (oasis didn't pay much attention to his report and the customer support gives answers that is far from the idea of what happened to his account) .. Few days after that he logs in back using his one of alt accounts and said that he will be back at the 7th day from the day his account got locked and he came back, he asked for my account and recharged little amount of ingots for me to Impeach his character and take over the Leadership of our Group ..

The only thing that changed in my account was, i became a Leader of the Group .. Nothing else, nothing more .. If recharging even for 1 time means removing your F2P status then i am a P2W, who never had anything to make my self victorious in battles, never had anything that boost my power insanely or just the literal meaning, never Win a battle because my account recharged of some ingots ..

About the image proof, that is not accurate to validate ones account from being a F2P or P2W .. And getting Gaara fragments from that, can automatically tag you as a P2W .. 4star Gaara is not a simple ninja that F2Ps can get in his/her early ages in the game (i 4starred my Gaara when i reached Lv90s) .. And obviously, if you have a 4star ninja, you will use it rather than making him just for transformation .. Thus, making you to have advantage on your battles, making you to win with ninja that you payed to get .. inshort it is P2W stuff ..

..