Perfect! Thanks to reading the reply, I just managed to plunder at 9.10pm (server time), when the convoy window ends at 9pm.
And it seems that the convoy support didn't activate. I spoke to that person right after (well, he spoke to me cause he was pissed), and he had a group mate support, but it didn't appear. So I'm wondering, that is either a bug, or support doesn't work past the actual event time window.